If your child is making their First Holy Communion, chances are the cake is already on your to-do list. Communion cakes can end up looking like mini wedding cakes, with a price tag to match — but a homemade cake is a lovely way to keep costs down without losing any of the wow factor.
If the thought of cake decorating fills you with panic, don’t worry. We’ve pulled together a collection of easy Communion cakes that are genuinely achievable for a beginner baker, along with a few piping tips to help you along the way.
Don’t miss our best content straight to your inbox! Sign up now and get our FREE newsletters packed with fun ideas and things to do with the kids, family-friendly recipes, expert advice, parenting tips and great competitions.
Easy Communion Cakes to Make at Home
Simple Flowers
This cake is a great example of how effective simple decoration can be. Plain white icing is kept as the base, with tiny flowers used to trace the outline of a cross across the top. You can create the flowers with a flower plunger cutter, widely available online, or use sprinkles for a similar effect. Use a toothpick to gently mark out the shape of the cross first, then follow that line with your decorations.
Communion Cupcakes
Cupcakes are a lovely alternative to a traditional tiered cake. Simply bake a batch of your favourite cupcakes, ice them, and top each one with a sugarpaste plaque. Sugarpaste is easy to find in most supermarkets — roll it out thinly, then use a small cookie cutter (or even the rim of a glass) to cut your topper shape. Add a cross, a flower, an initial or a scattering of edible glitter to finish.
If you’d like to build your piping skills, it’s worth watching a short tutorial that shows how to create several different cupcake designs using just one nozzle tip — a great way to get four looks from one simple technique, perfect for beginners.
<iframe src=”https://www.youtube.com/embed/fcWwwGqvXWg” width=”100%” height=”315″ frameborder=”0″ allowfullscreen=”allowfullscreen”></iframe>
Communion Sheet Cake
If you’re feeding a crowd, a rectangular sheet cake is a practical, low-fuss option. Keep the decoration simple — a layer of white buttercream finished with a few fresh berries, fresh flowers or sprinkles looks elegant without requiring advanced skills.
Communion Dress Cupcakes
For something a little more creative, arrange cupcakes into the shape of a Communion dress and finish with a swirled buttercream design. It looks impressive but relies on simple piping rather than intricate cake decorating, which makes it a good option if you want a showstopper without the stress.
Cupcake Cross
Along the same lines, cupcakes can be arranged into a cross shape rather than a dress. The technique is the same — plenty of icing helps fill any small gaps between the cupcakes so the overall shape reads clearly.
Stained Glass Cake
This one looks far more complicated than it is. Start with a rectangular cake, then use a sharp knife to cut curved edges at one end to suggest the shape of a window. Make a batch of buttercream and divide it into separate bowls, colouring each one to match the shades you want for your “stained glass.” Use a light colour, such as white or pale yellow, to pipe the outline of the glass panes and a cross (or any design you like), then fill in the sections with your chosen colours. The finished effect is genuinely striking and makes a lovely centrepiece.
A Few Tips Before You Start
- Practise your piping on a plate or spare bit of icing before you start on the cake itself — it takes the pressure off.
- Keep your colour palette simple. Two or three colours plus white almost always looks more polished than a rainbow of shades.
- If you’re short on time, cupcakes are far more forgiving than a full tiered cake and are easy to transport to the venue.
- A calm, simple design often looks more elegant on the day than something overly fussy.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need special equipment to make an easy Communion cake?
No. Most of the designs above use basic kitchen equipment plus a few inexpensive extras, such as a flower plunger cutter or piping bags and nozzles. Sugarpaste and food colouring are widely available in supermarkets.
Are cupcakes a good option for a Communion cake?
Yes. Cupcakes are simple to bake, easy to decorate, and easy to serve to a crowd. They also travel well, which is handy if you’re bringing the cake to a party venue rather than making it there.
Can I make an easy Communion cake in advance?
Sponge cakes and cupcakes generally freeze well undecorated, so you can bake ahead and decorate closer to the day. Buttercream can also be made a day or two in advance and stored in the fridge until you’re ready to ice.
What if I’m not confident decorating cakes?
Start simple. A plain iced cake with a few flowers, sprinkles or a piped cross looks lovely and doesn’t require advanced skills. Piping tutorials are a great way to build confidence with just one or two techniques.
You Might Also Like
- 10 Inspirational Ideas for Homemade First Communion Cakes
- 30 Reasons to Know You’re the Mum to a First Communion Child
- 20 Alternative First Communion Gifts that are Not Money
- How to Throw a Stress-Free Communion Party at Home
Keep the Ideas Coming
Looking for more Communion planning inspiration? Browse our other First Communion articles for party ideas, gift guides and more ways to make the day special without the stress.
Want ideas like this delivered straight to your inbox? Sign up for our free newsletter for weekly recipes, activities and parenting tips.
